Daggett Shuler Logo
Your Injury and
Disability Lawyers
Personal Injury, Disability, and Workers’ Compensation
Safe sober 36 years logo

Common Mistakes That Can Hurt Your Workers’ Compensation Claim

Even small mistakes can hurt your workers’ compensation claim. Learn the most common errors injured workers make—and how to protect your right to benefits in North Carolina.

Published on April 16, 2026
Man with leg injury at work

No one expects to be injured on the job, and when it happens, it can turn your world upside down and leave you unsure of what comes next. While North Carolina’s workers’ compensation system is designed to provide medical care and wage replacement for injured workers, the reality is that even small mistakes can jeopardize your claim. Below are some of the most common mistakes injured workers make and how to avoid them.

Top Mistakes That Can Jeopardize Your Workers’ Compensation Claim

  1. Failing to report your injury promptly. One of the most critical mistakes is not reporting your injury right away. Under North Carolina law, injured workers generally have 30 days to notify their employer, but waiting can raise doubts about whether the injury is work-related. Even if your injury seems minor, report it immediately and make sure to put it in writing. Delays can lead to denied claims or unnecessary disputes.
  2. Not filing the proper paperwork. You must also file Form 18 with the North Carolina Industrial Commission to officially start your claim. Failing to file this form, or filing it late, can prevent you from receiving benefits altogether.
  3. Giving incomplete or inaccurate medical information. Your medical records are the backbone of your workers’ compensation claim. If you don’t explain how your injury occurred or downplay your symptoms fully, it can be used against you later.  Always be honest and thorough with your doctor. Even small inconsistencies can create doubt about your claim.
  4. Ignoring the doctor’s orders or missing appointments. Skipping medical appointments or failing to follow treatment recommendations can seriously harm your case. Insurance companies may argue that you are not truly injured or that you are making your condition worse. Consistent treatment shows that you are taking your recovery seriously and strengthens your claim.
  5. Returning to work too soon or without approval. It’s common for injured workers to feel pressure to return to work quickly. However, doing so without medical clearance can worsen your injury and give insurers a reason to reduce or deny benefits. Always follow your doctor’s restrictions and ensure any return-to-work duties are approved.
  6. Failing to document everything. Workers’ compensation claims rely heavily on documentation. Without proper records, it becomes your word against the insurance company. A lack of documentation can weaken even a legitimate claim. Be sure to keep:
    • Copies of written injury reports
    • Medical records and bills
    • Notes from doctor visits
    • Communication with your employer or insurer
  7. Not seeking a second medical opinion. In North Carolina, your employer may direct your initial medical treatment. However, you may have the right to seek a second opinion. Relying solely on the employer’s chosen doctor could result in premature return-to-work decisions or underestimated injuries.
  8. Accepting a settlement too quickly. Some injured workers accept settlements without fully understanding their long-term medical needs or disability rating. This can leave you without adequate compensation for ongoing care. Once a settlement is finalized, it is often difficult or even impossible to reopen your case.
  9. Trying to handle the claim alone. While it’s possible to file a claim without legal help, workers’ compensation cases can become complex, especially if your claim is denied or disputed.

How to Protect Your Claim and Maximize Your Benefits

An experienced North Carolina workers’ compensation attorney can:

  • Ensure deadlines are met
  • Handle communication with insurers
  • Protect you from unfair settlement offers

Failing to seek legal guidance is one of the most common and costly mistakes injured workers make.

Protect Your Rights from Day One

At Daggett Shuler, we help injured workers avoid these pitfalls and fight for the workers’ compensation benefits they deserve. If you’ve been hurt on the job, taking the right steps early can make all the difference in the outcome of your case. Need guidance on your workers’ compensation claim? Speak with a trusted workers’ compensation attorney you can depend on.

Contact us today by submitting an online form or calling our office at (336) 724-1234 for a free consultation.

Get a Free, No Obligation consultation today.

Our attorneys win millions for our clients every year

Rated 4.9 out of 5 on
Google Icon
2025 Daggett Shuler Attorneys Group Photo

Client Reviews

Our attorneys have helped clients with legal support through workers’ compensation, Social Security Disability, personal injury, car accident claims, and more. Our clients know that we stand beside them when they are going through a difficult time. Read reviews from real clients, and if you had a positive experience with Daggett Shuler Law, please consider leaving a review.

Thank You for Everything

I would like to take time to thank the staff at Daggett Shuler Attorneys at Law. To Megan Youngblood for helping me get my disability started; thank you so much for everything!

Outstanding

My experience with Daggett Shuler was amazing. James Cohn was the attorney I worked with for my workers’ compensation claim. He is an awesome attorney. I was injured while on the job performing my duties with a local company, and the next Monday was fired because they did not want to pay my medical bills. After going to Daggett Shuler they looked after me throughout the process. The Daggett Shuler team was outstanding in their professionalism and empathy.

Daggett Shuler Will Have Your Back

I was expecting it to take years to get disability and Daggett Shuler went above and beyond to get it as quickly as possible. They got the disability awarded in 6 maybe 8 months tops. I would recommend Daggett Shuler to anyone filing a disability claim. These guys will have your back for sure!

Made the Process Easy

From the time I called to the time everything was settled, Daggett Shuler made the whole process very easy. Griff was my attorney; he was very professional and handled my case very well. I’d recommend them for anyone in need of this service.

Totally Awesome

My wife got approved for social security disability in 6 months with no appeals or denials. These guys are totally awesome. Totally recommend them for anything.

Made the Process Easy

I was referred to Daggett Shuler by a family member and I’m glad they did! From the time I called to the time everything was settled, they made the whole process very easy They were very professional and handled my case very well. I’d recommend Daggett Shuler for anyone in need of this service.

Went Above and Beyond

I have had really low vision my whole life and recently got to the point to where I couldn’t work anymore. I was expecting it to take years to get disability and they went above and beyond to get it as quickly as possible. I would recommend Daggett Shuler to anyone filing a disability claim. These guys will have your back for sure! I wouldn’t trust anyone else with your claim! Seriously… These guys are the best.

Outstanding Team

I was injured while on the job performing my duties with a local company, and the next Monday was fired because they did not want to pay my medical bills. After going to Daggett Shuler and being accepted for my claim, they took me in as family and looked after me throughout the process. The Daggett Shuler team was outstanding in their professionalism and empathy. David Daggett and Griff Shuler have put together an outstanding team.

Very Helpful

Everyone was very helpful with my case, any questions I had were answered quickly and I could tell they really had my best interest in mind always.

Fantastic Experience

I had a fantastic experience with Daggett Shuler. The dedication and professionalism shown throughout the process were truly remarkable. The way you handled every aspect of my situation put me at ease and instilled confidence in the outcome. I’m grateful for the expertise and support you provided. Thank you for your outstanding service!

Couldn't Be More Pleased

A wonderful law firm who personally takes care of your issues. Workers’ Comp can be a nightmare in so many ways so it is good to have an exceptional attorney with that experience guiding you through the process. Griff Shuler was my attorney and I couldn’t be more pleased with the way he handled my case.

Awesome Staff

Awesome staff and very friendly. Took care of my needs without hesitation and helpful in every aspect! Thank you guys for all your hard work!

Have a question?

Talk with us for free

Contact us today to get started with a free, no-obligation consultation.

You Can Depend On Us

Contact Form

Serving People Across North Carolina

Contact the attorneys at Daggett Shuler today for a free, no-obligation consultation. You can depend on us.